Cllr Jim Swift: ‘Scotland – home of Hume, Smith and The Enlightenment has slipped and tripped and is falling.’ (Part 2)

Jim Swift lives in Newton Mearns, is one of three Conservative Councillors elected for the Newton Mearns South & Eaglesham ward, and is a professional health economist.  Education is one of many interests pursued by Cllr Swift, and we present the second instalment of his guest article on the Scottish Government’s proposals to centralise control over our schools.

It is very strange that the Scottish Government demand ever more powers from London, yet do not devolve any, but demand ever more powers from our communities too. They are control freaks and their desire to micro-manage every aspect of our lives, especially when they will do it much worse should be resisted. The “named person” scheme is but one example of control seeping into aspects of our lives where Government has business being involved.

I remember a discussion a decade ago with the then Director of Education in East Renfrewshire, a man considered by many to be pre-eminent in his field and the head of the education authority with the best exam results in Scotland and asking him if there had been any slippage in standards in teaching or education. He defended the profession and his life’s work with the passion and vigour I would have expected. However, when asked if Highers had got easier in his time in education. He immediately responded with “in 1992”.

I confess I had thought it mythical, the inexorable slide in exam difficulty described by many.  Not so, the slide has been real and over generations. Does anyone now know anything about grammar before they learn another language? Declining nouns and conjugating verbs, never mind past participles, gerunds and split infinitives, anyone, anyone? Thought not, but this was in the syllabus for primary school but two generations ago.

When I sat my higher Latin in 1982, it was 55% seen, which meant in theory it could be passed without knowing any Latin and there was no English into Latin translation, nor interpretation exercise; all of which my father recalled in his day. Was the Latin Higher noticeably easier in one generation? You bet it was and by a very substantial margin.

If we cannot conjugate verbs or translate English into Latin, does this matter? Does exam difficulty correlate with educational attainment? Does dumbing down education have any harmful effects?

Does that translate into how Scotland will fare in a globally competitive world?

PISA showed that Scotland has declined versus other first world countries and some other lower players.

Scotland that always seems to want to judge itself by its nearest neighbour and had always fared better has now been surpassed by England. Where we have always prided ourselves on the universality of access to higher education, which despite differing policy choices; e.g. offering free access to tertiary education now also falls behind England in the proportion of less affluent young people going to university. Yet this was perhaps the key driver behind the policy choice.

Brighter pupils in Scotland are one year behind where they were only a decade ago in science. Scotland is doing less well in education and that decline has been one of long run poor choices. Why over the last decade have things managed to get markedly worse here in Scotland?

Historically Scotland spends more on education per capita than England and still does. We spend more but it would seem that for the first time ever we are getting less. Our devolved government has introduced “Curriculum for Excellence” and not to universal acclaim nor for that matter universal condemnation. There appear to be good and bad bits, but if introducing changes to a system that is failing, why are their bad bits? If the Government in Holyrood believed it would turn things around, why did they cancel the schools numeracy and literacy tests?

Devolution has meant divergence in choices and thereby divergence in outcomes. If we are unwilling to change policies that aren’t working or learn from other areas with policies that are, then we aren’t being very bright.


Subjectively, I would suggest it might be a government wedded to ideas carved into stone that clearly aren’t working to our advantage that is a very significant part of our problem.

But to the point at hand does this matter?

It matters directly for our education industry, as the policy choice of free education means that many places have to be sold to foreign students to subsidise our own students and those from other EU countries that are also “free”. Our universities drop year after year in the UK league tables, Stirling and Dundee, a recent rise from Glasgow and the notably excepted Edinburgh & St Andrews our only first class universities have maintained a good reputation. If you are paying through the nose, who wants to go to a so-so university.

It matters socially because the traditional route of the least affluent who missed out on the full fruits of education the first time round into education, the colleges have been gutted to pay for free university education. The traditional route out of poverty has been education and in an ever more knowledge based economy, it is even more relevant. The loss of 142,000 places has implications and not least in social mobility and that the ladder out of poverty has been lifted out of reach for many.

It matters because the money spent on education that is driving perverse outcomes is money that can’t be spent on other things or even on the bits we all agree are useful. It matters because if the SNP want the fairer society that they maintain they do and to reduce inequalities that they insist matter, policies that are clearly managing to deliver the opposite outcomes should no longer be promoted.

We all make mistakes, electorates tend to forgive them if they are admitted early, are admitted with humility and most importantly reversed. Electorates tend to be less forgiving when mistakes are not just ignored, but carved into stone.

Cllr Jim Swift: ‘Scotland – home of Hume, Smith and The Enlightenment has slipped and tripped and is falling.’

Jim Swift lives in Newton Mearns, is one of three Conservative Councillors elected for the Newton Mearns South & Eaglesham ward, and is a professional health economist.  Education is one of many interests pursued by Cllr Swift, and he has written a guest article for our website on the Scottish Government’s proposals to centralise control over our schools.

The Scottish Government has proposed to bring East Renfrewshire’s schools under a new regional education centre and it is to happen by June 2018.  This will include all the schools in the West of Scotland.

The current education authority is the Council, where we have a long tradition of delivering improving performance. Whilst the Conservatives have been in opposition on East Renfrewshire Council, we have however supported the Administration in its prioritisation of education in every budget and in every education committee meeting.

The changes risk the quality of local schooling and the high flying performance that our schools and most importantly our young people have enjoyed. In stark contrast to the high quality of local levels of educational attainment, we have the Scottish Government’s woeful record.

Scottish education was the envy of the world. Other countries regarded our system of education as amongst the foremost in the world.

International tests looking at literacy and numeracy show we have slipped down the international league tables and our place in the world has diminished. It is bad that we have been overtaken by England, Wales and Northern Ireland, even by Slovenia, which was in the midst of a civil war only a generation ago. In all 3 areas; reading, maths and science we have recorded our worst scores ever.


Scotland – home of Hume, Smith and the Enlightenment has slipped and tripped and is falling.

Our own internal Scottish tests of numeracy and literacy have shown such a substantial decline over the last 6 years that the Scottish Government has cancelled doing them.

You read that correctly, just in case you doubted it.

Just because the SNP has stopped measuring the extent to which things are deteriorating does not mean that things have stopped getting worse, it just means less bad headlines.

Given their record on burying bad news and being less than straight with the public, should we stand idly by while they try to wrest control of education from a successful Council?

We believe that more control needs to be given to head teachers and that element of the proposed reforms makes sense, but the rest of it is nonsensical. There is now a proposed imbalance of responsibility and accountability, the Council is responsible for hiring and the HR and facilities management, but not the actual school management. Lastly, the democratic deficit, we spend proportionately more on education than other Councils and that is a democratic decision. We care here, this is our community and have worked hard to deliver great educational attainment. Furthermore sacrifices have been made in other areas to deliver the resourcing of that. The new regional education centres will be managed by ministerial appointees not local people.

Who will replace the high quality team of professionals who uniquely measure every aspect of a child’s performance and ensure teachers are aware of any slippage, so teachers can act before children fall behind? Who will replace those that fill the void of Curriculum for Excellence with meaningful content? What will replace the ethos of the schools, the working together but healthily competing environment?

A regime led by Scottish Government place people. If the fiasco that was the Scottish Police Authority is an example, then we will get more people questioning the finer points of the uniforms for Police, now read school children and missing the big stuff, like the huge financial hole (£21Million), which went un-noticed. I would contend that an organisation that refused to take advice from England because they had a system that worked for paying farmers and we still don’t, i.e. an organisation that fails to learn and is worse than that, unwilling to learn is not the kind the kind of organisation we want controlling our children’s education.

The proposals to take the controls over schools in East Renfrewshire out of the hands of the Council and put them in the hands of SNP place people in regional education centres should concern not just parents with children at our schools, but everyone.

It should concern us, not just because the SNP’s record on education is pretty awful, but because by contrast, our local record is good and is accelerating away from the rest of Scottish school attainment.

(Part two of this article to follow soon)

Cllr Miller seeks Clarkston – Stamperland – Busby “Green Network” participation

Councillor Stewart Miller

East Renfrewshire Council have provisionally been awarded £100,000 through the Sustrans Community Links programme for the first phase of a Clarkston – Stamperland – Busby “Green Network”. This aspiration – for a network of well-connected and attractive cycling and walking routes for community and visitors – was identified as a local priority during the September 2016 Clarkston Town Centre charrette.

In order to realise funding, ERC are looking to develop a ‘Green Network Delivery Plan’ for the area. This will detail a spatial strategy outlining key active travel corridors as well as specific interventions that could be delivered to enable more people to walk and cycle more often. The Delivery Plan, supported by Community Links investment in 2017/18, will represent the first stage of a long term plan to improve active travel provision in the area.

We are currently seeking views from stakeholders, including businesses and community groups, as well as members of the public to help inform plans and proposals. Planned activities include:

– An interactive online ‘placecheck’ for the area http://www.placecheck.info/maps/clarkston . This will allow people to make comments regarding things they like, don’t like and things that need fixed, in order to identify opportunities or issues at specific locations. (see attached information).
– A community drop in session Wednesday 23 August 2017 between 1-6:30pm at Clarkston Halls (see attached poster)
– Informal on-street questionnaires
– Opportunity for further face-to-face discussions and/or walking/cycling infrastructure tours 4-8 September 2017 with council officers (should demand exist)

I would be grateful if you could circulate this information amongst your contacts and networks across the area.

If you have any questions or wish to discuss this project further, please do not hesitate to get in touch.

Cllr Stewart Miller is Scottish Conservative & Unionist Councillor for Ward 4 ‘Clarkston, Netherlee & Williamwood’.